Torch Electronics will pay Missouri $13.5 million over three years and must keep its gambling machines out of convenience stores, bars and other for-profit businesses. The deal, announced November 16 by Attorney General Catherine Hanaway, resolves pending civil and criminal investigations. Torch did not admit violating Missouri gambling law or accept liability.

The first $4.5 million is due this week, followed by two more annual payments of the same amount. A further $6.5 million penalty applies if Torch breaks the terms, according to the Missouri Independent as cited in the reporting. The money goes to the Gaming Proceeds for Education Fund, which supports school district grants through the Classroom Trust Fund. The agreement also shields Torch, its owner Steven Miltenberger, employees and associates from state prosecution as long as they comply.

The carve-out matters most. Bona fide nonprofits, including veterans' groups and fraternal halls, may keep the machines, and Torch can add qualifying nonprofit locations until January 1, 2027. Hanaway said the state focused on commercial operators because they made private profits, while nonprofits used proceeds for community initiatives and members. She also said companies cannot get around the rules by creating nonprofit subsidiaries or changing corporate form.

Analysis: the line Missouri has drawn runs between who keeps the profit, not between legal and illegal machines. That is a policy choice, and the deal does not settle whether the games are gambling. A federal judge found in February that chance was involved, which strengthened the state's case, but the machines could return if the legislature legalises video lottery terminals or if a final appeal favours Torch.

The cost falls on businesses that hosted the machines. Torch suspended its machines in retail locations in April under pressure from the attorney general and the threat of criminal proceedings. The reporting does not give figures for lost revenue, staff or the number of Torch machines affected, so the human cost of the April shutdown is not measured here. Hanaway estimated about 25,000 illegal devices statewide before the crackdown, but the settlement does not break that total down by operator.

The $13.5 million is less than the state originally sought, which was based on 21% of Torch's gambling revenues. Hanaway declined to say what the original demand was and conceded it is hard to estimate what the company earned in the past, so readers cannot judge how large the discount was. The settlement's full text and any court approval would show the exact terms and how "bona fide non-profit" is defined, which would change how much the nonprofit exemption is worth to Torch.

SOURCE & CERTAINTY

This file draws on a public report from Gambling News. Its source type is industry; we label this story reported. Analysis and reported claims are not independent confirmation.

Read the source