U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained a Princeton University Ph.D. student at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport as she tried to fly back to New Jersey after presenting research at a conference, NBC News reported, in a case that turns a routine domestic journey into an immigration test.
Eva Yi Xie, 24, is a third-year neuroscience student from China. Her lawyer, Kerry Doyle, told NBC News that Xie has had an asylum application pending for a decade, after arriving in the United States with her family at 14, and had permission to live, work and study while that case remained unresolved.
The Department of Homeland Security gave the opposite account. In a statement cited by NBC, DHS said Xie was admitted temporarily in March 2016, was required to leave by Sept. 15 of that year, and remained in the country after that deadline. The agency also said she had “never” held valid authorization to study in the United States and argued that a pending application does not itself create legal status.
That disagreement is the whole hinge of the case. If Doyle is right, ICE detained a student who was lawfully continuing her life while the government took years to decide her claim. If DHS is right, the government is treating even a domestic airport gate as an enforcement point for someone it says should have left long ago. Either way, the practical message is hard to miss: getting from a conference back to campus is no longer just a travel question for some migrants with unresolved cases.
NBC reported that Xie was being held at the Caroline Detention Facility in Bowling Green, Virginia, according to ICE’s detainee search tool. Doyle has filed a habeas corpus petition in federal court in Virginia challenging the arrest, arguing ICE lacked grounds to detain her without a warrant because she was neither a flight risk nor a danger to the community.
Princeton has arranged legal representation. Graduate school dean Rodney D. Priestley said Xie’s arrest was distressing for the university community and that the university would stay in contact with her legal team, family and colleagues.
Her adviser, Carlos Brody, said Xie had been presenting work on links between decision-making in the brain and navigation through space. He also said that from detention she was still trying to keep experiments moving and grant applications submitted. That is one of the uglier details here: the state can stop a researcher at an airport faster than it can decide the case that governs whether she gets to go home.
Marcus Azzopardi
Alex de Valletta
Harvey Jr.
Gabriel Fenech