The European Commission has sent Malta a reasoned opinion ordering it to stop authorising finch trapping, giving the government two months to respond before the dispute can be referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union, Times of Malta reported.
That is not a press-office reprimand. It is the last formal step before the Commission asks the court to act. The legal position set out by Brussels is blunt: Malta’s derogation “does not pursue a genuine research purpose” and “inappropriately uses the research derogation for continued recreational hunting despite previous court rulings”.
The Commission also said Malta had failed to demonstrate that no other satisfactory solutions existed and had not ensured appropriate enforcement. In infringement language, that is the part doing the work. The argument is not about whether ministers say the right words. It is about whether the derogation meets the conditions of the Birds Directive in practice.
This fight is not new. The EU court condemned Malta’s yearly recreational finch-trapping derogations in 2018. A further judgment in September 2024 found Malta had again breached EU bird protection law over derogations presented as research, after failing to justify why alternative research methods could not be used.
The Commission said Malta then adopted new finch-trapping derogations for the 2024, 2025 and 2026 autumn seasons that were similar to the one struck down in 2024. It also pointed to 2025 changes in Malta’s legislative framework that, in the Commission’s view, relaxed enforcement and reduced the involvement of scientists from the European Union in implementing the research derogations.
That is the central disagreement. Malta is still defending the scheme as research. The Commission is saying the derogation is being used to continue trapping that the courts have already found unlawful when dressed up as recreation, and unlawful again when repackaged as research without meeting the directive’s tests.
The government said it remained committed to defending the research derogation while ensuring compliance with EU law and protecting Maltese and Gozitan traditions. Tradition may be the domestic argument. It is not the legal standard the Commission is applying.
What changed on Thursday was not the trapping season itself but the pressure on the Maltese state. Brussels has now formally moved the case forward and stated that Malta should stop authorising finch trapping.
Marcus Azzopardi
Alex de Valletta
Dua Mifsud