Finance Minister Clyde Caruana told parliament he was paid between €80,000 and €90,000 to compile a report on the impact of rapid population growth that has still not been published, Times of Malta reported.
Caruana said the work was done in a personal capacity as an economist, outside work hours, and took about a year. He said the report was later passed to the Office of the Prime Minister during Joseph Muscat’s time in office, and that he would publish it if he obtained written permission.
That shifts the dispute from the report’s existence to control of it. Caruana says he wrote the document but is not the one who can release it. Prime Minister Robert Abela, meanwhile, said a day earlier that he had neither seen the report nor had a copy of it. Between those two public positions sits the unanswered administrative question: who can actually authorise publication?
The existence of the 300-page report was already on the record. What changed in parliament was the fee. PN MP Michael Piccinino asked how much Caruana had been paid and in what capacity he had carried out the work. Piccinino also raised the question of a possible conflict of interest. Caruana replied that he was entitled to express professional opinions independently of his official role.
That answers one part of the matter and leaves the awkward part intact. A minister has now put a price on the report, but not an end to the circular explanation around it. He says he is the author, not the report’s “destination”. Abela has said he does not have it. The document remains unpublished.
The chamber even managed a joke out of it. As Piccinino questioned Caruana, Abela entered, patted him on the back and asked, “Found it?” The line was lighter than the record underneath it.
The Nationalist Party said after Caruana’s remarks that he was still avoiding publication of a report “the country paid thousands for”. That is the opposition’s allegation, not a settled finding from the exchange in parliament. The narrower verified point is sufficient on its own: Caruana says he received €80,000 to €90,000 for a report on population growth, and the government still has not produced the document or plainly identified who can release it.
Marcus Azzopardi
Alex de Valletta
Dua Mifsud