An appeals court has scrapped Environment and Planning Review Tribunal decisions on two Sliema hotel permits linked to developer Carlo Stivala, sending both cases back to the tribunal even though one of the hotels is already operating, Times of Malta reported.
That is the part Malta’s planning system keeps trying to treat as normal: the appeal is still alive, the building is not waiting, and by the time the law catches up the concrete may already have won.
In two judgments on separate hotel applications on The Strand, Judge Mark Simiana found that the tribunal had misapplied the law when it refused objectors’ request to suspend the permits while appeals were pending. The court revoked the tribunal’s decisions and ordered it to reconsider the cases from scratch.
In the St Vincent Street case, involving a 15-storey hotel still under construction, the court said the tribunal was wrong on two fronts. It should have considered suspending the permit during the appeal, and it should not have ordered amended plans as part of its final decision without first allowing appellants to inspect those changes and make submissions on them.
The judgment, as quoted by Times of Malta, was unusually clear about the consequence of letting works continue under a permit still under challenge. If a permit is later revoked after the development has been carried out, the result is an illegal state of affairs that harms public order. That is not decorative language. It goes to the basic question of what an appeal is for if the subject of the appeal is allowed to materialise first.
Judge Simiana also described the tribunal’s treatment of the suspension request as “rather superficial” and said it failed to show the request had been genuinely considered. He further noted that the tribunal had continued using the same flawed procedural approach despite previous court judgments setting out the correct interpretation of the law.
The second judgment concerns the Sliema Centric Hotel above Piccolo Padre, a 79-room project on The Strand. That permit was also sent back to the tribunal because objectors were not given the chance to file observations on amended plans. According to the report, the hotel has already been built.
Claire Bonello, lawyer for objectors Din l-Art Ħelwa and Moviment Graffiti, told Times of Malta this was not an isolated mishap but a recurring tribunal practice: amended plans are introduced, objectors are shut out of commenting on them, and development carries on while the appeal process drags behind. She said urgent applications have now been filed seeking an immediate hearing and a decision without further delay.
Her description was combative. The court’s finding was narrower and more useful: a tribunal exercising public authority failed to apply procedural safeguards that already existed and had already been clarified by earlier judgments.
That distinction matters. The court has not cancelled the developments outright. It has not ruled on every planning merit raised by objectors. What it has done is something both more limited and more awkward for the institutions involved: it has said the appeals process itself was handled unlawfully.
For the Planning Authority and its tribunal, this is the less theatrical but more damaging kind of rebuke. Not a quarrel over aesthetics. A finding that the machinery meant to review planning decisions is still operating as if the right to appeal can be fitted around construction works rather than the other way round.
One of the hotels is open. The tribunal now has to reconsider the cases from the beginning.
Marcus Azzopardi
Elena Vella