The Planning Authority has opened an enforcement case against the Bidnija “sheep farm” development it approved in 2019 and later accepted should never have been permitted.
As Newsbook reported, the case follows the end of a court fight over the permit’s revocation. Judge Wenzu Mintoff dismissed a request for a retrial, clearing the way for the authority to move from the long argument over paperwork to the more awkward question of the building itself.
That shift matters. Malta’s planning system is crowded with permits, appeals and tidy policy language, but what changes a place is usually concrete already on the ground. In Wied tal-Ħżejjen, that concrete stayed put while the permit behind it unraveled.
The original application, filed in 2018 by Jason Vella and architect Konrad Bezzina, was for the construction of a farm with ancillary facilities on ODZ land. Newsbook said the application drew no objections at the time. The Environment and Resources Authority raised concerns about building in such a sensitive area, but the case officer still recommended approval and the planning commission approved it unanimously in February 2019.
The objection came after construction, not before. Once works were under way, the emerging two-floor building appeared to many critics to look nothing like a modest agricultural structure. Public anger sharpened further in 2022, when a separate application sought to convert the site into an agritourism complex with guest rooms, dining space, retail uses, “educational agri-experience” areas and a farmer’s residence.
That second application was eventually withdrawn in 2023 after drawing more than 1,000 objections. By then, six NGOs and other objectors had also moved against the original permit under Article 80 of the Development Planning Act, arguing that it involved an error on the face of the record. The PA accepted in April 2024 that there had been such an error, though it initially argued the application should be reprocessed rather than cancelled.
The Environment and Planning Review Tribunal sided with the NGOs’ push for outright revocation, and that outcome was later confirmed in court. The enforcement case is what comes after all that: not another debate over intent, but a formal notice saying the works on site are illegal.
According to Newsbook, notice EC/142/26 names Vella and Bidnija Farming Enterprise as contraveners, with Bezzina also named as the architect. It covers the whole footprint of the previously approved application and appears to treat everything built on site as unauthorised. The notice refers to soil removal, excavation, construction of a multi-level structure, roof solar panels, boundary walls and a greenhouse on land scheduled within the buffer zone of the nearby watercourse.
The notice is still only a first step, and that is where the story turns familiar. Enforcement in Malta has a habit of arriving after the landscape has already been altered, then moving at a pace the building never did. Newsbook noted that daily fines have not yet started to accrue; they begin 15 days after the notice is issued. The harder question is not whether the PA can open a file. It is whether a revoked permit in a sensitive rural area leads to demolition, or to another long season in which an illegal structure remains standing while procedure catches up with masonry.
Alex de Valletta
Dua Mifsud
Marcus Azzopardi