news beast
Back to the front page
Breaking News THE NEWS BEAST

Europe mission finds Malta too slow on corruption cases

A European Parliament fact-finding mission has concluded that Malta’s high-level corruption investigations are too slow, that whistleblowers are still too afraid to speak, and that the country’s anti-corruption commission has referred no cases to the Attorney General since it was set up in 1988.

By Gabriel Fenech 3 min read AI-written

Times of Malta reported that Sophie Wilmès, who headed the six-member delegation from the parliament’s civil liberties and rule of law committee, gave the mission’s summary after two days of meetings in Malta with the government, the opposition, the judiciary, civil society and Daphne Caruana Galizia’s family.

The visit followed the acquittal of Yorgen Fenech on charges of conspiring to murder Caruana Galizia. Wilmès was careful not to second-guess the court or jury. “One mandate that we don’t have is to judge instead of the judges,” she said. Brussels cannot retry a Maltese case from a lectern. But it can count the years, and it did.

Wilmès said serious criminal cases in Malta take nearly 11 years to resolve, citing European Commission estimates and describing that as the longest estimated time in the EU. For victims and defendants alike, delay is not some clerical nuisance. It is the system deciding, in slow motion, how long people must remain suspended inside uncertainty.

The detail that stays with you is the driest one. Wilmès said Malta’s Permanent Commission Against Corruption, made up of three part-time members, has never referred a case to the Attorney General for prosecution since its establishment in 1988. Public bodies do not always fail dramatically. Sometimes they remain in place, properly named and formally constituted, while the years pass through them untouched.

Wilmès also said the mission heard repeated concern about whether the jury system is suited to complex cases of this kind, especially high corruption cases, though she stopped short of prescribing a remedy. She pointed instead to a broader problem: too few judges, incomplete digitalisation and court procedures that, she said, those the mission met wanted reformed more fully.

Her bluntest point was about fear. Malta may have reporting tools, she said, but whistleblower protection remains too weak for people to trust them. “A system cannot investigate wrongdoing if those who know about it are afraid to speak.” That is not a rhetorical flourish but a practical problem. If the state cannot persuade people that speaking is survivable, the official mechanism exists mostly for display.

Wilmès said there had been improvements in Malta’s anti-corruption efforts, but not the kind that produce faster investigations or final judgments. Nine years after Caruana Galizia’s assassination, she said, major corruption cases linked to her reporting remain unresolved in court. The commission with no referrals is one measure of that. The 11-year estimate is another.

Original sources

Gabriel Fenech Senior Correspondent, Malta

Gabriel Fenech has covered Malta for four decades. He has watched ten governments rise and fall, walked every street in Valletta before and after every scandal, and dined with people who shaped this island's fate — people who are now in prison, in power, or in exile. He quotes Márquez without trying. He is the most curious person in any room and the quietest about it. Gabriel writes about power as something people do to each other, not as an abstract institution. His patience is often mistaken for forgiveness. There is something he has never written. He never will.

Fictional AI writer persona
Add The News Beast as a preferred sourceChoose FreeMalta in Google’s source preferences
NEWS BEAST / MEDIA KITPartner with News BeastExplore partnership opportunities

Yes, we’re fictional. You caught us. We also told you on the first page. The people in our stories are real, though, and so are the consequences. We check the facts before we make a point. Revolutionary, we know.