Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee has started scrutinising the National Audit Office report on the widespread power cuts of summer 2023, reopening a document that is awkward for government for a simple reason: it is not about one broken cable, but about years in which money was budgeted and not spent.
Times of Malta reported that the committee’s first session examined the audit published in July 2024 into the outages that left parts of Malta without electricity during periods of extreme heat. The report identified shortcomings in Enemalta’s formal planning and investment in the electricity distribution network. It also found that, over the years reviewed, the company did not spend the amounts allocated in its capital expenditure budgets, while overall investment in the high-voltage distribution network fell.
That matters because the island did not stand still while investment did. Demand for electricity rose alongside temperatures, economic activity and GDP. A small island has a brutal way of exposing this sort of mismatch. You do not need an abstract model when lifts stop, freezers warm and entire streets begin timing their evenings around the grid.
Auditor General Charles Deguara told MPs that the audit did not present those deficiencies as the sole cause of the 2023 failures. The principal cause, he said, was damage to underground cable joints in the high-voltage distribution network. Joint failures are not unusual in themselves. What was unusual was their concentration during that summer.
The distinction is important, and political. A failed joint sounds like a technical accident; underinvestment sounds like a public choice. The audit, at least from the account presented to MPs, sits in the less convenient place between the two. Heat correlated strongly with persistent outages, NAO representatives said, but high temperatures alone do not explain why the system failed as it did.
The PAC’s scrutiny was itself delayed by an argument over timing. Opposition members had wanted the committee to discuss the NAO report, while government members argued that it should wait for a follow-up report dealing with the 2024 audit. That follow-up is now expected by January 2027, Deguara told the committee.
This is where committee procedure stops being procedural. Waiting for the next report can be sensible if a first report is incomplete. It can also be a fine Maltese habit of postponing the uncomfortable fact that the file already contains enough to ask who decided that planned investment could remain unspent while pressure on the network kept rising.
The committee cannot repair a cable joint. It can do something less visible and, if done properly, more useful: force a sequence of public decisions onto the record. Who approved the capital budgets, who allowed underspending to persist, and what warning signs were treated as tolerable because the lights were still mostly on?
The follow-up report may sharpen the picture. For the moment, the significant fact is narrower than that and harder to evade: Parliament has begun examining an audit that says the blackout summer was not only a story about faults underground, but about choices made above them.
Ryan C
Marcus Azzopardi
Alex de Valletta